4 Best MUD\WTR Products for Beginners

Disclosure: This page contains affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you purchase through our links at no additional cost to you.

I've introduced MUD\WTR to probably a dozen people at this point. Friends, family, coworkers who kept asking "what's that?" when they saw me making it. And I've learned something: the product you start with makes or breaks whether you stick with it. Pick wrong and you'll think the whole brand isn't for you. Pick right and you'll understand why people get a little evangelical about this stuff.

Here are the four best starting points, ranked by how likely they are to win over a first-timer. I left out Mushroom Boost (it's a supplement add-on, not a standalone drink) and :rest (it's a nighttime sleep blend, not a morning coffee replacement).

1. MUD\WTR Coffee+: Best for Coffee Lovers

If you're a total coffee person who's never had anything but Folgers, Starbucks, or your local roaster, start here. Coffee+ is the only MUD\WTR product with real Arabica coffee beans in it, so it actually tastes like coffee. I gave this to my brother-in-law (a black coffee, no compromises guy) and he said "oh, that's actually good" on the first sip. That's a win.

Behind that familiar flavor, you're getting 2,250mg of functional mushrooms (Lion's Mane, Chaga, Reishi, Cordyceps) and 125mg of L-theanine, the amino acid that takes the jittery edge off caffeine. At 45mg of caffeine per serving, it's about half a regular cup of coffee. Most people don't notice the lower caffeine on day one because the L-theanine fills in the gap. You feel alert but smooth.

Why it works as a first product

• Zero taste adjustment. It tastes like coffee because it is coffee (plus mushrooms)
• Highest L-theanine in the lineup (125mg), so the energy feels familiar even with less caffeine
• Easiest transition from regular coffee with minimal withdrawal
• You can mix it 50/50 with your regular coffee for an even more gradual switch

Who should skip it

• People who want to get away from coffee flavor entirely
• People who want the lowest possible caffeine (Original is lower at 35mg)

Start with Coffee+

2. MUD\WTR Original: Best for Adventurous Palates

This is the product that built the MUD\WTR brand, and it's still their bestseller. Fair warning: it tastes nothing like coffee. Not even a little. It's a rich blend of cacao, chai spices (cinnamon, ginger, cardamom, nutmeg, cloves), and functional mushrooms. Think spiced hot chocolate with earthy depth.

I've seen the reaction to Original go two ways. Some people try it and immediately say "oh wow, this is great." Others take a sip, make a face, and say "this isn't coffee." Both are valid. But here's the thing: I've watched that second group come around by day 3 or 4 almost every time. My mom was firmly in the "this isn't coffee" camp. By week two she was ordering her own tin. With oat milk and a little honey, this drink is genuinely delicious. The 35mg of caffeine from black tea is the gentlest energy option. The 2,240mg mushroom blend plus turmeric gives you the most complete nutritional profile in the lineup.

Why it works as a first product

• Most universally loved flavor once your palate adjusts (give it 3 to 5 days)
• Lowest caffeine of the morning blends, ideal if you're trying to cut way back
• Most complete ingredient profile with turmeric, cacao, and chai spices
• The "classic" MUD\WTR experience that most fans end up recommending

Who should skip it

• People who only drink coffee for the coffee taste and won't budge
• People who need a familiar flavor from day one (try Coffee+ instead)

Start with Original

3. MUD\WTR Matcha: Best for Tea Drinkers

If you already like matcha or green tea, this is a no-brainer starting point. You know the flavor territory, so nothing will feel weird on day one. MUD\WTR Matcha uses ceremonial-grade matcha and pairs it with the highest mushroom dose in the entire lineup: 3,000mg per serving, including 750mg of Lion's Mane.

I recommended this to a friend who was already a matcha person but curious about mushroom coffee. She texted me the next morning: "Why does this feel different from my regular matcha?" That's the L-theanine (naturally occurring in the matcha) working with the mushroom blend. At 55mg of caffeine, it sits in the middle of MUD\WTR's range. Higher than Original's 35mg, still well below regular coffee. If focus and mental clarity are the main reasons you're interested in mushroom coffee, Matcha delivers the most on that front. It's the one I use for work days (more on that in our focus guide).

Why it works as a first product

• Familiar flavor if you already drink matcha or green tea
• Highest mushroom dose (3,000mg) means more functional benefit from day one
• Natural L-theanine creates smooth, jitter-free energy
• Best MUD\WTR product for focus and cognitive support

Who should skip it

• People who dislike matcha or earthy green tea flavors
• People who want the lowest caffeine option (Original is lower)

Start with Matcha

4. MUD\WTR Turmeric: Best Caffeine-Free Starting Point

Maybe you already quit caffeine. Maybe you never started. Maybe you're pregnant or just don't want stimulants. Turmeric is your entry point. It's a golden latte blend built around turmeric (with black pepper for curcumin absorption), cacao, warming spices, and 1,840mg of functional mushrooms. Zero caffeine.

I gave this to my neighbor who's a yoga instructor and has been caffeine-free for years. She was skeptical of anything called "mushroom coffee" but loved it immediately. The flavor is warm, slightly sweet, and genuinely pleasant. Especially with oat milk and a drizzle of honey. It works as a morning ritual, an afternoon warm-up, or just whenever you want something cozy. The anti-inflammatory benefits from the turmeric-black pepper combination are a real bonus that you won't find in any of the caffeinated options. This is also the easiest MUD\WTR product to start because there's no withdrawal risk, no sleep disruption, no adjusting to caffeine levels. Just a good drink with functional ingredients.

Why it works as a first product

• Zero caffeine, zero risk. No withdrawal, no sleep issues, no jitters
• Drink it any time of day
• Approachable golden latte flavor that most people enjoy immediately
• Anti-inflammatory turmeric with enhanced absorption from black pepper

Who should skip it

• People who want caffeine in their morning drink
• People looking for a coffee replacement (this doesn't taste or function like coffee)

Start with Turmeric

My Recommendation for Most Beginners

If you're coming from regular coffee and you just want the smoothest possible switch, go with Coffee+. You'll barely notice the change on day one, and the reduced caffeine plus added mushrooms start making a difference within the first week. That's what I tell anyone who asks.

If you're willing to try something genuinely different, go with Original. But promise me you'll give it 5 days with oat milk before you judge. The flavor grows on almost everyone, and it delivers the most complete nutritional profile of any MUD\WTR product. That's the one I recommend to people who I know will actually stick with it long enough to adjust.

Whichever you pick, start with a single 30-serving tin. One month. That's enough time to evaluate it fairly. Check the MUD\WTR website for current pricing and any introductory offers for new customers.

Browse All MUDWTR Products